i disagree. peyton is one of the best qbs i've played with in this madden. every throw is accurate and on point. its just that you can't run around with him and expect to get accurate throws. you might be able to do that with vick and rogers but not with brady and manning. if you use the pocket and keep your movement to a minimum, the dude is deadly. its just that the only problem with that is the colts o-line is trash. so you might need to roll out every now and then, but he's not gonna give you accurate throws all the time if you pass without letting him set his feet first.
but with that said, i think the trade is fair. fletcher is old but the dude is still good. moss is good, might decline a little but still good. so them two for peyton is in the colts favor a little bit. helu is ok but collie is nice. i think the collie add-in makes the trade fair. so i approve